Private Credit Isn't Defaulting. It's Deferring.

When a borrower can't pay, it defaults. That used to be the rule. In America's private credit market, there is now a third option: don't pay, don't default — defer.

On October 14, Moody's Ratings published an assessment of 607 US private credit borrowers that quantifies how much stress that third option is hiding. The headline default rate across the sample was 4% for the twelve months through June. But when Moody's counted payment-in-kind (PIK) amendments and maturity extensions granted to distressed borrowers — maneuvers the agency treats as distressed exchanges, economically equivalent to default — the rate rose to 5.8%. Measured that way, actual credit stress is running roughly 45% above what the headline number admits.

Interest, Paid in IOUs

Payment-in-kind is exactly what it sounds like: instead of paying interest in cash, the borrower adds the interest to the loan balance. The lender books income it hasn't received; the borrower buys time with money it doesn't have. Used sparingly, it's a legitimate bridge for a company in a rough quarter. Used broadly, it's a mechanism for converting today's credit problem into a larger one later — with the added feature that nothing shows up in default statistics along the way.

The breadth is what has changed. In Moody's sample, 17% of borrowers were using PIK interest, and the profile of those borrowers is not reassuring: weak liquidity, negative free cash flow, high leverage, and interest coverage sitting near break-even. Software borrowers showed the weakest overall credit metrics in the sample; business services had the heaviest concentration of weak liquidity among PIK users.

The Federal Reserve Bank of Boston reached a similar conclusion from a different direction in August. Studying the portfolios of business development companies — the publicly reporting vehicles that hold a meaningful slice of private credit — researchers found the share of BDC loans carrying PIK arrangements rose from roughly 6% to roughly 10% in three years, with construction-sector loans jumping from under 5% to nearly 20%. Their verdict: rising PIK usage signals "broad-based pressure on the cash flows of middle-market borrowers." More striking, lending spreads narrowed by about a percentage point over the same period — competition eroding lending standards even as the borrowers weakened.

Analysis like this is free to read with a free AlphaBriefing membership — join at AlphaBriefing.com in about thirty seconds.

The Year the Deferral Economy Went Public

None of this is happening quietly anymore. In February, Blue Owl restricted redemptions from its retail-focused private credit fund OBDC II — abandoning quarterly withdrawals in favor of periodic distributions — after a wave of redemption requests that followed its scrapped merger plan for the fund, and disclosed a $1.4 billion loan sale across three funds to raise cash for investor payouts. By the end of March, LSEG data showed listed BDCs trading at a median 26% discount to forward net asset value — the widest gap since October 2020. In May, the Financial Stability Board warned that the roughly $2 trillion global private credit market had vulnerabilities that could transmit stress to banks and insurers.

The official American position remains calm. The Fed's own assessment this year called risks from private credit "limited and manageable," and Chair Powell has said that while investors will lose money, he does not currently see systemic risk. That may well be right. But here is the tension: the lenders say their portfolios are worth roughly par. The market prices the same portfolios at the steepest discounts in five years. Moody's just told you part of why — a measurable slice of "performing" loans is performing only in the sense that nobody has made them pay cash yet.

Somebody is wrong, and the trade is in knowing who. The rest of this briefing works through it: where the listed BDCs are trading right now, name by name; what the 2027–28 maturity wall does to the deferral math; and the five indicators that will tell you — starting with the Q3 filings in the coming weeks — whether this resolves quietly or doesn't.

The rest of this briefing is free — it just requires a free AlphaBriefing account: the live BDC tape and what each discount implies, the maturity-wall arithmetic for 2027–28, and the five-indicator watchlist for the next two quarters of filings.

Create your free account → — 30 seconds, no card.