The Coffee Shortage Is Over. The $9 Pound Isn't.

Arabica coffee futures in New York traded around $2.90 a pound on Monday. That is a 4% bounce on the day — and it still leaves the market down roughly 16% for September and about 31% below the peak above $4.22 it hit last November.

Now walk into an American grocery store. The average price of a pound of ground roast coffee was $9.30 in August, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data — just 4% below the record $9.72 set in April, and still up nearly 5% from a year earlier.

One of those two prices is telling you the coffee shortage is over. The other hasn't gotten the memo. The gap between them is where the money is.

The Surplus Nobody Priced

For two years, the coffee trade ran on one story: not enough beans. Drought and frost damage in Brazil, a weak cycle in Vietnam, and exchange inventories grinding down to multi-decade lows pushed futures above $4 a pound.

That story ended this month, in three data releases.

The global balance flipped. On September 10, the International Coffee Organization projected that 2025/26 world production rose 4.4% to a record 183.6 million bags while consumption slipped 0.9% to 180.6 million — a surplus of roughly 3 million bags, the first in five years.

Brazil confirmed a record crop. On September 24, Conab — Brazil's official crop agency — raised its 2026 estimate to 67.6 million bags, up 19.6% from 2025 and the largest harvest in the history of its survey. Arabica output is expected to jump 34.8% to 48.2 million bags. Yields rose almost 14% to 34.6 bags per hectare, the harvest is 99% complete, and planted area grew 5%. This is the "on" year of coffee's natural biennial cycle, amplified by favorable weather and heavier use of irrigation and inputs.

The beans are already moving. Cecafé, Brazil's exporters' council, reported record August shipments of 4.16 million bags, up 31% year over year — with robusta exports up 54%. And the weather is cooperating with next year's crop too: Somar Meteorologia recorded 33.4 mm of rain in Minas Gerais, Brazil's main arabica belt, in the week ended September 20 — 242% of the historical average — right in the flowering window that sets the 2027 harvest. Vietnam, the world's top robusta producer, shipped 13.7% more coffee in January–August than a year earlier, with its 2025/26 crop forecast at a four-year high.

Supply came back. It came back everywhere at once.

The Antwerp Tell

Here is the detail that tells you the squeeze is genuinely over, not just pausing.

In mid-September, ICE-certified arabica stocks — the exchange warehouse inventories that back the futures contract — fell to 217,646 bags, the lowest in 27 years. In the old regime, that headline alone would have been read as rocket fuel. Instead, the market fell.

Why? Because the trade knew what was coming. Reuters reported on September 11 that trading houses had large shipments en route specifically to rebuild exchange stocks. The UK importer DRWakefield spotted it in the export data: Brazil shipped 537,429 bags to Belgium in August — up 282% from a year earlier, nearly as much as it shipped to the entire United States. Belgium is not drinking that coffee. Antwerp is the main delivery port for ICE's European warehouses, and the certified stockpile duly rebounded to 258,415 bags within days.

When record-low inventories stop being bullish, the market is telling you the physical shortage has ended. Robusta exchange stocks are already at a 10-month high. Add a stronger dollar — the Fed's September hike took rates to 3.75–4.00% and pushed the dollar index back above 100 — and a weaker Brazilian real that encourages farmer selling, and every pillar of the two-year bull market is gone.

Which leaves the question that actually matters for your portfolio and your kitchen counter: if wholesale coffee has crashed by a third, why is the shelf price still within sight of its record — and who pockets the difference while it stays there?

Get the next briefing free in your inbox: Join AlphaBriefing

The rest of this briefing is free — it just requires a free AlphaBriefing account: the futures-to-shelf lag and why retail prices fall on a delay measured in quarters, the packaged-food names positioned to recapture margin as hedges roll off, the tariff wildcard in the US–Brazil talks, and the three catalysts that could reignite the squeeze.

Create your free account → — 30 seconds, no card.